Censorship: Do Book Bans Benefit Society?
Ask yourself
if book bans benefit anyone. After
attending a recent book signing of world-renowned author Jodi Picoult, this
issue was raised. One of many of her
books are on banned lists in some states. One book is banned simply for having
the word erection in one sentence in the middle of the entire book. Is this
cause for alarm?
Hitler instituted these types of bans on the masses with an alarming speed. There were literally book fires in the
streets of all the books his government ‘decided’ no one should have access to.
Years of work in history, the arts and self-expression went up in flames. Destroyed relics, literal pieces of history,
based on what? A few getting to determine what the population at large can
write about and what can be read. Does
this have value for an evolving society or is this more the actions of a regime
that wants to control all aspects of the populace by attempting to control
their thinking?
Implementation
of banning is questionable and harmful. Writing is another art form and
minimizing its impact is similar to not allowing great works of art (paintings,
sculptures, tapestries, dance, musical compositions) to have been created and
shared. With leaders bent on a dictatorship, the thought process is to dumb
down the masses. Thinking, in their
minds, invites resistance. Does it work?
Looking back
throughout history, any time people are repressed they do revolt. E.g. Russian Revolution, Freedom Train for slaves,
Revolutionary War, Resistance during Nazi occupation, etc. You cannot stifle all
of the people’s spirits. The Romans tried and after Jesus was crucified, He
gained even more followers and following. In the long-haul, it does not work.
And its costly.
America is
at a crossroads. Government is not addressing the masses’ needs. Repressing
literature is not going to change the reality of it. Putting a few in control of implementing standards
of what is acceptable will do nothing but build hostilities. Perhaps that is
why the majority of Americans are opposed to book bans, across party
lines! The same people pushing the Bible
in schools recognize that in that book is sinful things but they feel the
message is worth hearing. Even many of them are not in favor of book bans.
So, who is behind this action that is taking
over at alarming rates? Small pressure groups and government officials.
That’s right, not who you would think, concerned parents or grassroot groups. This small group is yielding their power over
something they hope you don’t wake up and notice as swiftly it’s happening, More
and more books are swept off the library shelves and deemed too mature for
people to read, too sensitive a topic and countless other excuses for repressing
their access. Don’t you think you have a
right to make that decision yourself?
It is telling
that one of the strongest pieces of history from Nazi Germany was writings by a
young girl locked up in a small room in a house, The Diary of Anne Frank. Who hasn’t heard of that? Yet under Hitler,
it would have been a banned book. Ask yourself
why? Because it did not serve the paradigm the leader was trying to push. If it
didn’t serve his narrative. The writing
freed up Anne’s mind so that she was not always felt captive. Do you think prohibiting children from reading
and writing about topics being others deem too harmful is somehow going to be
benefit children? Ask a school teacher
or a parent how many times they have used a story, usually from books, to
address a difficult topic with their child.
Freedom of speech, of writing what you want to write and reading what you want to
read should be an indelible right. Plato, Aristotle and Eratosthenes wrote about
the world not being flat and were highly criticized, at one point for it. Should
their writings have been banned since it wasn’t the prevalent thinking at the
time? No, because the expressions in those writings were eventually challenged
and studied to further validate their writings!
We need to read, all views and not just the ones that mirror our
thoughts. Critical minds explore unchartered thoughts. Works of all artforms lends itself to this.
Take this issue to heart! Raise awareness. Books contain ideas, they contain dreams and
story-telling. Since the beginning of time, man is masterful at story telling. It has been an integral part of any civilization with staying power that fosters growth and change. It documents history. And writers exist, in part, because of readers. Don’t deprive today’s youth of what you were awarded the opportunity to do, explore horizons in a safe place, a book.
If you want freedom of choice, let your congressmen know, your educational boards, your library and use your vote to make your opinions known!


Comments
Post a Comment